Balancing Compliance and Innovation in Pharma Procurement

Mar 17, 2023 | Procurement in manufacturing industries

Stawan photo


Mar 17, 20234 mins

Pharmaceutical procurement requires a delicate balance between cost control and access to innovative medications. Robust logistics and inventory management systems are needed to maintain product integrity, while regulatory standards and intellectual property protection must be upheld. Successful procurement is crucial for delivering life-saving medications and ensuring company success.

Key Takeaways

  • Pharmaceutical procurement operates within a highly regulated environment, with strict quality standards and compliance requirements. 

  • Global pharmaceutical supply chains are complex, requiring robust logistics and inventory management systems to ensure product integrity. 

  • Safeguarding intellectual property is critical in procurement to protect innovative drugs and prevent counterfeiting. 

  • Demand volatility and effective inventory management are crucial for successful pharmaceutical procurement, avoiding stockouts and minimizing waste. 

  • Procurement professionals face intense pricing pressures, necessitating a delicate balance between cost control and access to innovative medications. 

Navigating the intricate landscape of procurement in the pharmaceutical industry presents a unique set of challenges that distinguish it from other sectors. The pharmaceutical industry operates within a highly regulated environment, facing intense pricing pressures, demand volatility, and the need for innovation. Procurement professionals in this field are tasked with striking a delicate balance between cost control and ensuring access to innovative, high-quality medications. Additionally, they must tackle complex supply chains, manage product expiration dates, and safeguard intellectual property rights. Despite the challenges, effective procurement in the pharmaceutical industry is critical for delivering life-saving medications to patients and ensuring the success of pharmaceutical companies. Here’s a deeper look into common procurement challenges faced by pharmaceutical companies across the globe. 

Stringent Regulatory Environment 

The pharmaceutical industry operates within a highly regulated environment, governed by stringent quality standards and compliance requirements. Regulatory bodies such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the United States and the European Medicines Agency (EMA) in Europe enforce strict regulations to ensure patient safety and product quality. This complex regulatory landscape significantly impacts procurement processes, supplier selection, and qualifications. For example, the process of qualifying suppliers involves rigorous audits, inspections, and compliance assessments to ensure adherence to regulatory standards.

In 2020, the FDA conducted over 1,200 inspections of pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities in the United States and overseas, leading to thousands of regulatory actions. Non-compliance with regulatory requirements can have severe consequences, including product recalls, fines, and reputational damage. One notable example provided by a report by the U.S. Department of Justice is the case of Ranbaxy Laboratories, which faced penalties exceeding $500 million for multiple violations of manufacturing standards. According to a report by McKinsey, pharmaceutical companies invest in robust supplier qualification processes, quality assurance systems, and ongoing monitoring to ensure compliance with regulatory standards to navigate this regulatory landscape. These measures are essential for maintaining product quality and meeting the stringent regulatory expectations of the pharmaceutical industry. 

Global Supply Chain Complexity 

Pharmaceutical supply chains are complex and often extend globally, involving multiple countries, suppliers, and intermediaries. Managing this intricate network presents significant challenges in terms of logistics, transportation, inventory management, and supplier relationships. Pharmaceutical companies must ensure the integrity and traceability of their products throughout the supply chain while addressing issues such as temperature control, product serialization, and proper handling of sensitive materials. 

According to a 2019 McKinsey report, the global pharmaceutical industry loses approximately $15 billion annually due to supply chain inefficiencies and disruptions. For instance, the counterfeit Avastin scandal in 2012 exposed vulnerabilities in the pharmaceutical supply chain, highlighting the need for enhanced traceability and supplier management. Pharmaceutical companies now leverage technologies like blockchain and RFID for improved visibility and authenticity. They also implement rigorous supplier qualification, temperature-controlled transportation, and robust inventory management systems to ensure product integrity. These measures address the complexities of global pharmaceutical supply chains, mitigating risks and ensuring the safe delivery of medications. 

Intellectual Property Protection 

The pharmaceutical industry heavily relies on intellectual property rights and patents to protect innovative drugs. This creates a unique challenge in procurement in the pharmaceutical industry as companies must balance the need for competitive pricing and quality with the protection of intellectual property. Ensuring that suppliers respect and maintain confidentiality is critical to safeguarding proprietary information, trade secrets, and patents. Additionally, companies must address concerns related to counterfeiting and intellectual property infringement, which can have severe consequences for patient safety and brand reputation. 

The importance of safeguarding intellectual property in the pharmaceutical industry is well illustrated in the case of Pfizer's Viagra. According to a FDA report, Pfizer invested heavily in research and development to bring Viagra to market as a breakthrough medication for erectile dysfunction. However, before the patent expiration, counterfeit versions of Viagra started to flood the market, resulting in revenue losses for Pfizer and potential risks to patient health. 

Demand Volatility and Product Expiry 

The pharmaceutical industry faces demand volatility influenced by factors such as changing demographics, disease outbreaks, and regulatory shifts. This volatility adds complexity to procurement planning, as companies must accurately forecast demand, manage product expiration dates, and minimize inventory waste. The expiration of pharmaceutical products carries significant financial and regulatory implications, requiring precise inventory management strategies to avoid stockouts or excess inventory. 

The pharmaceutical industry encounters demand volatility due to factors like shifting demographics, disease outbreaks, and evolving regulations. This volatility presents procurement challenges, with companies needing to forecast demand accurately and optimize inventory levels. According to an article by ABC news, improper inventory management results in an estimated $10 billion worth of expired pharmaceutical products each year. Effective planning and inventory optimization are crucial to mitigate financial losses and ensure timely access to medications. 

Pricing Pressures and Cost Control 

The pharmaceutical industry faces intense pricing pressures and increasing scrutiny on drug pricing, both from governments and healthcare payers. This puts procurement professionals under significant pressure to balance cost control with the need for innovative, high-quality medications. Strategies such as strategic sourcing, supplier negotiations, and value engineering are vital to optimize costs while ensuring access to safe and effective medications. 

The pricing pressures faced by the pharmaceutical industry can be seen in the case of Sovaldi (Sofosbuvir), a breakthrough Hepatitis C medication. Upon its launch, Sovaldi was priced at $84,000 for a 12-week treatment course in the United States. This high cost led to negotiations and discounts with healthcare payers to ensure access. Despite the controversies, Sovaldi became a blockbuster drug, generating billions in revenue. This example illustrates the challenges procurement professionals face in balancing cost control and access to innovative medications. 

In the intricate landscape of procurement in pharmaceutical industry, success hinges on mastering the delicate balance between compliance, innovation, and cost efficiency. Procurement professionals need to be proficient in their ability to navigate this complex environment, ensuring patient safety, driving innovation, and controlling costs. In this ever-evolving industry, the key to success lies in the hands of those who can adeptly procure life-saving solutions while maintaining equilibrium amidst the many challenges and the pursuit of better healthcare outcomes. 

FactWise is a unified E-procurement platform with a fully integrated suite of procurement products. Our modular, extensible source-to-pay solution is flexible: it is applicable across industries and can be adapted to diverse procurement organizational setups. The platform is used by global product manufacturing companies to transform their procurement organization via analytics and automation to reduce costs, improve supplier diversity and strengthen supplier relationships, mitigate risk, meet ESG goals and standards, and increase compliance and efficiency.   

At FactWise, we are committed to building truly distinctive procurement software solutions that delight users and provide sustainable positive impact to the organizations we serve. We do this by providing transparency and insights to leaders (31% increase in governance), streamlining and automating processes to improve efficiency (20% increase in efficiency) and driving bottom-line impact by unlocking savings potential (25% cost reduction for direct spend).  

About the Author

Stawan is the founder and CEO of FactWise. Before founding FactWise, Stawan was the NA TMT-Procurement Leader at McKinsey. Passionate about procurement, Stawan has 15 years’ experience in enabling clients of all sizes to achieve business impact via procurement.


Show all

No comments to show

Suggested Articles



Privacy Policy

Terms & Conditions

©Copyright 2024. FactWise. All Rights Reserved.